advertising, Uncategorized

Advertising. Anybody fancy building a dangerous cathedral?

“We don’t see things as they are, we see them as we are.

Anais Nin

There is a story about three men who spent their lives quarrying rocks. When asked what they were doing, one replied, “Breaking rocks.” The second said, “Earning a living.” The third said, “Building a cathedral.”

Perception. In advertising, it is often aimed or focussed at the client or the project we are working on. We are always looking outward. It is very seldom that we have a clear point of view about ourselves. I remember once being told by a friend the main reason ad agencies make such bad ads about themselves is because an eye finds it very difficult to look at itself.

This lack of depth and understanding is never more obvious than at the beginning of the year when people in the industry are asked what is important for the year ahead.

The answers I read were in a trade mag and what struck me was how similar the answers were. Almost everybody answered that creativity was the way forward. Initially that made me happy but then I got this weird feeling of dread. Really? These people all passionately believe in creativity? Half these people wouldn’t know what creativity was if it kicked them in the nuts. It was like some publicist had told them that creativity was the right answer. It was like they were going through the motions in a glitterless pantomime. They had made creativity just a word. And what’s worse, they had made it sound boring and unimportant.

This year it felt like these people were treading water in a pool of corporate correctness. They were waiting for something. Doing only what was required. There was no danger or audaciousness. It felt like they had no confidence or point of view.

There have been many that have said advertising needs to get its confidence back. The question is always how?

Before I answer that, lets look at the industry landscape. In the last 6 months, some of the greatest advertising agencies that have ever been have disappeared. Poof. Gone forever. Insert Kodak story.

Now, did they disappear because of what we all say is the most important thing in advertising. Creativity? No. Perhaps the work got worse in the end but I can promise you it wasn’t because the creatives didn’t try. I know, I spoke to them.

These agencies disappeared because people cared about the wrong things. These agencies disappeared because they became boring. These agencies disappeared because they stopped having a point of view. And creativity, became just a word. It stopped meaning anything. When that happens, no process, delivery mechanism or structure can save you. The centre cannot hold because you have nothing of value anymore. There is nothing to sell.

To answer the original question, confidence in our industry has always come from doing, not talking. That will never change. Turning creativity into a verb. Making shit. Astounding the world. Doing what has never been done. Doing what others won’t or can’t. Being brave and trying very hard to create a little magic. Doing will give us our confidence and in turn begin to change the way we see ourselves.

2019 is not the year where we have the luxury of simply going through the motions. We cannot give the same boring answers. We need to remember what we are capable of. We need to fight. We have to believe in creativity again. It cannot just be a word. We have to make it mean something. There is no other way.

As an industry, we need to remember that our confidence has always come from building dangerous cathedrals.

Standard

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s